EBENEZER (2026)
Starring Johnny Depp, Rupert Grint, Andrea Riseborough, Sam Claflin, Daisy Ridley, Tramell Tillman, Ian McKellen, Arthur Conti, Ellie Bamber, Nicholas Day, Charlie Murphy, Henry Lloyd-Hughes, Freddie Lee-Grey, Christopher Fairbank, Michael Culkin, Rose Williams, Franc Ashman, Sara Galvin, Zac Wishart, Eva Wishart, Scott Reid and Trevor Laird.
Screenplay by Nathaniel Halpern.
Directed by Ti West.
Distributed by Paramount Pictures. 116 minutes. Rated PG-13.
I love Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol. This must be distinctly understood, or nothing wonderful can come of the story I am going to relate.
I have read the novella multiple times. I watch a version of the film pretty much every year during the holiday season. I usually watch the 1984 George C. Scott version, my favorite version with my favorite Ebenezer Scrooge. However, I’ve seen many of the adaptations, and seen many actors take on the role. Some of them are fantastic, like Scott, Alastair Sim, Albert Finney, Patrick Stewart, Reginald Owen, Michael Caine and even an animated Walter Matthau. Others are harder to warm up to, like Jim Carrey, Guy Pearce, Bill Murray and Kelsey Grammer.
However, I have found something of value in most tellings of the tale, simply because the story is just so good that it is really difficult to completely mess up.
A Christmas Carol has been filmed so many times – both officially and in variations of the story – that there really would have to be something special coming from a new adaptation to make it worth watching over so many other choices. Horror filmmaker Ti West has decided in his variation to lean into the ghost-story aspects, at least somewhat. This is a good instinct, although it does not work well enough to really separate Ebenezer from the pack.
Screenwriter Nathaniel Halpern also sticks closer to the original narrative of the novella than many other versions, which often play fast and loose with the source material – cutting scenes and characters, nearly completely revamping or modernizing the classic dialogue, adding unnecessary action sequences. (Well, this one does add a few unnecessary sequences as well, but more of that later.)
However, toward the end, the screenplay takes some rather cynical plot liberties that work against the story’s core themes rather than enhancing them. It suggests that the filmmakers did not fully understand what they were adapting.
I won’t really get into the details of the plot, because pretty much everyone knows the basic storyline of A Christmas Carol – that a miserly businessman is visited by ghosts who show him his past, present and future in order to save his soul. And if you didn’t know the plot, you probably would not be considering the movie or reading this review.
So the big question is, does Ebenezer work? Does it add anything to A Christmas Carol lore? The answer is only sometimes. It has some wonderful sets, good special effects (although, honestly making the ghosts even scarier runs counter to the underlying themes) and some intriguing acting.
Sadly, the main issue with Ebenezer is Johnny Depp’s performance in the lead role – and I am saying that as someone who has mostly been a fan of Depp’s work and seems to share several obsessions with the man, including Ed Wood, “The Legend of Sleepy Hollow,” Jack the Ripper, Vanessa Paradis, Pirates of the Caribbean, and yes, A Christmas Carol. I seem to be one of five people in the world who deliberately ignored Depp’s extremely ugly divorce, which threw his career off track.
Now eight years later he gets his first chance back at a leading role in a major motion picture, and this is how he responds? Granted, it is hard to play Ebenezer Scrooge subtly, but Depp’s overacting here is rather stunning. (Perhaps only Jim Carrey did an even broader version of the role, but his version was at least partially animated.) Depp hides behind extensive makeup and extreme gestures, mugging for the camera with angry, shouting line readings which make his Scrooge hard to empathize with – and let’s face it, if the audience doesn’t want Scrooge to find redemption, what is the point of watching the story?
And one unnecessary scene when Depp’s Ebenezer gets swallowed up by his bed may be a post-modern nod at the actor’s breakout performance in A Nightmare on Elm Street, but it pulls the audience straight out of the story it is being told. Oh well, at least Scrooge didn’t go out in a spray of blood like the Elm Street character.
But this kind of thing happens with regularity in Ebenezer. Ti West’s decision to emphasize the story’s horror elements occasionally produces striking imagery, but too often the film replaces Dickens’ psychological and moral unease with more conventional scares.
It’s actually kind of interesting that he does not seem to get that Dickens’ story is effortlessly scary on its own – the visit of Jacob Marley’s ghost is horrifying, as is the graveyard scene – but the story is also looking at deeper emotional issues than mere fright.
For example, The Ghost of Christmas Past, as played by Andrea Riseborough, has been changed into an actual walking phantom; pale, dead eyes with halting speech and motion. By making her such a horrifying specter, it just makes it more difficult for her to do her very necessary work. And the Ghost of Christmas Yet To Come, always the most mercurial of the spirits, is eventually given a specific character trait which completely strains against Dickens’ intention for the figure. For the record, Tramell Tillman’s version of the Ghost of Christmas Present comes closer to straddling the line between the director’s haunted vision and the character’s historic purpose in the tale.
The rest of the casting is fine. Rupert Grint makes a perfectly adequate Bob Cratchit, although it’s weird to see a film in which Grint gets a bigger role than Daisy Ridley. Sam Claflin won’t make me forget Roger Rees as nephew Fred, but he brings the necessary gaiety to the role. And Ellie Bamber does a fine job of reminding us why Belle was always the one loss that set Scrooge down his particular path in life.
However, in the long run, Ebenezer perhaps does not bring nearly enough to the table to make it either a necessary or particularly worthy addition to the Christmas Carol canon. I can’t see Ebenezer supplanting anyone’s favorite version of this story. So, perhaps we should ignore this new version of the overdone classic tale and decrease the surplus population.
Jay S. Jacobs
Copyright ©2026 PopEntertainment.com. All rights reserved. Posted: November 13, 2026.
